Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| The Pridwin Hotel |
8.5 / 10 (61 Reviews) |
From 334$ | |
| Sunset Beach |
8.2 / 10 (8 Reviews) |
From 596$ | |
| New Haven Hotel |
8.4 / 10 (1865 Reviews) |
From 63$ | |
| Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area |
8.6 / 10 (1642 Reviews) |
From 109$ | |
| Montauk Manor |
9.0 / 10 (1237 Reviews) |
From 157$ |
View all photos
The Pridwin Hotel
From 334$
Featuring a restaurant, the 4-star The Pridwin Hotel Shelter Island lies in the rural area full of shopping sites like Beall & Bell Antique Store 4.1 km away. This hotel, located about 10 minutes' drive from Shelter Island, boasts a heated pool along with a steam room and a sauna.
Custer Institute & Observatory is approximately 6 km from the hotel, while Fireboat Firefighter Museum is 3.5 km away. A private beach is around 5 minutes' walk from The Pridwin Shelter Island. Also, visiting Greenport Antique Carousel, which is 3.8 km from this accommodation, can be great fun for the whole family.
View all photos
Sunset Beach
From 596$
Guests of the 4-star Sunset Beach Shelter Island hotel can enjoy easy access to Sunset Beach, which is situated nearly a 5-minute walk away. The hotel features 20 rooms and such amenities as a restaurant.
Camera Obscura is 3.1 km from this Shelter Island hotel, while Railroad Museum of Long Island is 2.9 km away. Attractions about 25 minutes' walk from the accommodation include Shelter Island. The hotel allows you to enjoy the vicinity of Conkling Point, which is around 9 km away. Along with other cultural attractions Horton Point Lighthouse Nautical Museum is nestled approximately 15 minutes by car from the property.
View all photos
New Haven Hotel
From 63$
Located 3.4 km from the 20-acre public Edgerton Park, which offers the thrill of discovering something beautiful, the 3-star New Haven Hotel offers a convenience shop and luggage storage. A vending machine and a lift are also provided for guests' advantage.
You'll be 700 metres from Chapel Square Mall Shopping Center and within reach of Little Italy. Attractions within walking distance include the central square "New Haven Green" and Center Church Crypt. There is Long Wharf a mere 1.9 km away. College/Crown bus stop is also situated just near this New Haven hotel.
Cheap Hotels
View all photos
Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area
From 109$
The 3-star smoke-free Hyatt Place Uncasville - Casino Area hotel is situated within a 6-km distance of Gallery at the Wauregan, which is an excellent place to improve cultural awareness. Featuring Wi-Fi in public areas, this Uncasville hotel also has amenities such as a restaurant and luggage storage.
Nestled around a 10-minute ride from Marina at American Wharf, the hotel is within 25 minutes' walk of Kids Quest. Religious sights in the area include First Baptist Church of Norwich (4.8 km) and Saint Davids Episcopal Church (3.7 km). Staying at the Hyatt Uncasville, guests get perfect access to Three Rivers Community College - an educational site located 3.2 km away.
View all photos
Montauk Manor
From 157$
The 5-star smoke-free Montauk Manor Hotel is situated merely 1.8 km from Saint Therese of Lisieux Church and features massage therapy, a shared lounge, and a golf course. Here, guests can take advantage of a hot tub and a sauna and visit the large Ditch Plains Beach, located approximately a 10-minute drive away.
Also, Second House Museum is 3.6 km from this Montauk hotel. Guests can also reach Camp Hero State Park within a 25-minute walk.
Hotels in Shelter Island
| Top Service Hotel 🛁 | The Pridwin Hotel |
| Top Hotel for couples 💑 | Sunset Beach |
| Hotel with balcony 🌤️ | New Haven Hotel |
View all photos
Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods
From 119$
Families with kids will appreciate the 3-star Hilton Garden Inn Closest Foxwoods Preston's entertainment offerings, with highlights such as children's activities and cinema.
The inn is conveniently situated approximately 2 km from Foxwoods Resort Casino and approximately 25 minutes' walk from Fox Arcade. Montauk is also 40 minutes' drive away from this Preston hotel. Travellers will enjoy proximity to entertainment attractions like the foxwoods Resort casino "Festival Buffet", which are 2.5 km away.
Pet Friendly Hotels
View all photos
Old Town Inn
From 155$
Located within a 10-minute drive of the red - Southeast Brick Lighthouse, the comfortable Old Town Inn New Shoreham offers Wi-Fi in public areas and parking.
The hotel offers location merely 1.9 km from Sacred Labyrinth. The nearby cultural experience includes Island Free Library, which is approximately 20 minutes' walk away.
View all photos
Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area
From 99$
Situated 2.6 km from Tantaguideon Indian Museum, the 3-star Fairfield By Marriott Inn & Suites Uncasville Mohegan Sun Area offers a casino and a golf course. The hotel is situated in the centre of Uncasville, not far from such cultural attractions as Samson Occom Bridge.
19 minutes' walk from this smoke-free hotel you will reach Casino Of The Earth. The Fairfield stands 4.3 km from First Baptist Church of Norwich, popular with pilgrims and tourists alike. Lobby bus station is a short way from the property, and the American Mohegan Sun Casino is 24 minutes' walk away.
View all photos
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
From 79$
Dog Friendly Hotels
View all photos
Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury
From 113$
The 3-star Hilton Garden Inn Hartford South/Glastonbury provides proximity to Putnam bridge plaza, which is located a mere 1.3 km away. This Glastonbury inn features a lift and a vending machine as well as a restaurant and luggage storage.
The hotel offers location approximately 25 minutes' walk from Keeney Cove Marsh State Wildlife Area. Families travelling to Glastonbury will enjoy being around 7 km from Bushnell Park Carousel.
View all photos
Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino
From 144$
Located approximately a 15-minute drive from the expansive Mashantucket Pequot Museum and Research Center, the 3-star luxury Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino North Stonington offers general facilities such as a lift and a vending machine. With a location within a 6-km distance of Foxwoods Casinos, this North Stonington inn also features two jacuzzis.
The centre of North Stonington is a 20 minutes' walk of the hotel. Norwich is 17 km from Bellissimo Hotel, Trademark By Wyndham Near Foxwoods Casino, while the ascending trails "Lantern Hill" is nearly a 10-minute ride away. The accommodation stands 2.9 km from North Stonington Congregational Church, popular with pilgrims and tourists alike.
View all photos
Hyatt Place Mystic
From 114$
The 3-star smoke-free Hyatt Place Mystic hotel is situated a mere 450 metres from Palmer House and provides modern rooms, which are merely an 11-minute walk from Olde Mistick Village Pond. Staying at this perfect hotel, guests discover the popular area a short way from the interactive Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration.
The hotel places you around 3 km from Fields Of Fire Adventure Park Recreation Center and around 7 km from Stonington Vineyards. Sights, approximately 10 minutes by car from the Hyatt Mystic, include Shady Oaks Park. Travellers will enjoy proximity to entertainment attractions like Historic Downtown Mystic Marina, which are 2.5 km away. This accommodation is also situated within 25 minutes' walk of Mystic train station.
Kid Friendly Hotels
View all photos
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg
From 99$
The 3-star Holiday Inn Express & Suites Meriden By Ihg also includes a lift and a vending machine.
Merimere Reservoir is located 4.8 km from this Meriden hotel while the 892-ft Higby Mountain is approximately a 10-minute drive away. The roadtrip to Hampton Bays takes 60 minutes.
View all photos
Hilton Mystic
From 119$
Located approximately 25 minutes' walk from Mystic River Park, the 4-star Hilton Mystic Hotel offers amenities such as a sunbathing terrace and a picnic area. Featuring an indoor pool, this Mystic hotel is 2.8 km from natural sights like the 140-acre Pequot Woods Park.
The hotel is merely 500 metres from Mystic Luxury Cinemas, while Historic Downtown Mystic Marina is nearly 30 minutes' walk away. The Hilton Mystic is within a 300-metre distance of Foxwoods Marine Theater, and Fields Of Fire Adventure Park Recreation Center, where guests can indulge in relaxation, stands 3.5 km away. The - art Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration is just steps from the property. Mystic railway station is about 25 minutes on foot from this hotel.
View all photos
Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area
From 99$
Situated about 25 minutes' walk from a shopping hub like the modest Trading Cove, the smoke-free Microtel Inn & Suites By Wyndham Uncasville Casino Area provides guests with a convenience shop and a lobby area. The 3-star hotel provides a lift and a vending machine, plus Wi-Fi in public areas and parking on site.
Nestled 3.2 km from the performing arts theater "Cabaret Theatre", the hotel is 2.4 km from the American Mohegan Sun Casino. The Microtel Inn & Suites Uncasville is also approximately 10 minutes' drive from Three Rivers Community College. The location will allow you to be 2.5 km from Casino Of The Earth.
Hotels Downtown
View all photos
Harbor View Landing
From 259$
Located 3.3 km from Morgan Point Light, the 2-star Harbor View Landing Hotel Mystic offers air-conditioned rooms just 5 minutes' walk from Hoxie Scenic Overlook. Staying active is easy with a tennis court available for guests at this elegant hotel.
The hotel boasts a scenic location in a shopping district, in the immediate vicinity of Mystic Market West. Denison Pequotsepos Nature Center is a popular education place to visit within 3 km of the Harbor View Landing. This accommodation also takes you to the - art Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration, which is approximately 10 minutes away by car. The nearest train station, Mystic, is a mere 1.5 km away.
View all photos
Home2 Suites By Hilton East Haven New Haven
From 156$
View all photos
Hyatt Place Long Island East End
From 114$
The 3-star Hyatt Place Long Island East End Riverhead hotel offers air-conditioned rooms in a business district, just a 5-minute walk from Suffolk Theater. Located 2.1 km from Safari Adventure, the hotel offers views of the river and a heated pool.
The centre of Riverhead can be reached within a 10-minute walk, and natural attractions like Splish Splash Water Park are about 15 minutes away by car. Long Island Aquarium is within a 200-metre distance of the Hyatt Place, and The Big Duck is 3.1 km away. Riverhead United Methodist Church is just a stone's throw from this smoke-free hotel. E Main St/Ostrander Ave bus stop is located nearby, in close proximity to the property.
5 Star Hotels in Shelter Island
View all photos
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
From 101$
The comfortable 3-star Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg is around a 25-minute stroll from Ferry Park and has an outdoor swimming pool plus a fitness room. The smoke-free hotel, offering 18 holes of golf, is conveniently situated next to the business district of Rocky Hill.
This Rocky Hill hotel has a convenient location 2.8 km from the educational center "Dinosaur State Park and Arboretum", while shopping venues like Wethersfield Shopping Plaza Shopping Center are approximately 2 km away. Great Meadow Shopping Center stands right near the Holiday Inn Express Rocky Hill. The area also includes natural sites like Glastonbury Historic District Park, which are nearly a 15-minute ride from the accommodation. Hartford-Brainard airport is situated 5 km from the hotel.